Comments on: Galliano Strikes Back: Defamation Lawsuit Filed Against Couple Who Alleged Anti-Semitism http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism Lifestyle Intelligence Sun, 27 Feb 2011 22:08:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.3.4 By: Signature9 http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5173 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 22:08:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5173 In reply to Anonymous.

It’s important to realize that at this point these are still allegations. As someone who isn’t a native French speaker, I’ve commonly had people in France hear something entirely different than what I was actually saying.

We have no idea what language the insults were traded in, what the couple may or may not have said to provoke a response, etc.

We also have no idea if Galliano is a closet racist who went off after too much to drink (remember Seinfeld’s “Kramer”? No one saw that coming).

We say Galliano is striking back because at this point he has his side of the story, the couple has theirs. They made the first strike by filing charges, Galliano is striking back saying that the charges are not only wrong, but defamatory.

Since no one can be sure yet, I do agree that the suspension was appropriate, but I’m not convinced it’s so cut and dry that Galliano is a mean, racist drunk.

-YM

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5172 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:54:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5172 Dior has in no way thrown him to the wolves. They have to take a position on this. He has been suspended, not fired, until the investigation is completed. Dior has to acknowledge what is being said and show that they do not take it likely. Merely saying that they will make a statement after the investigation is completed would not show that they care greatly about these types of things. Suspending him however does show to the rest of the world that claims of anti-semitism are not taken lightly.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5171 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:35:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5171 In reply to Anonymous.

I think the statement Dior made was quite wrong. If they felt it necessary to make a statement it should have been along the lines that Dior acknowlege an incident has taken place involving their head designer and they will be in a position to make a statement when the facts are determined and the investigation has been completed.

As everyone knows, Dior is not really suspending Galliano as a lot of money rides on his upcoming collection which is to be shown on March 4. To say that they have suspended him immediately sounds like they have prejudged the case and do not support him in any way.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5169 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:24:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5169 In reply to Anonymous.

Dior has merely responded to the fact that he is currently being investigated for these claims. They have not said that they think he is guilty or not. They have merely said that he is on suspension because there are people that claim he has made these comments. Their response is completely expected given that he is being investigated. They have to show some sort of response to what is being said.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5170 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:24:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5170 In reply to Anonymous.

Dior has merely responded to the fact that he is currently being investigated for these claims. They have not said that they think he is guilty or not. They have merely said that he is on suspension because there are people that claim he has made these comments. Their response is completely expected given that he is being investigated. They have to show some sort of response to what is being said.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5168 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:19:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5168 I have no idea what the defamation laws are like in France, but I can understand why Mr Galliano feels compelled to make use of them. From the first sensationalist, nasty and inaccurate reports, the media (and especially the internet) has spread rumour as fact.

This must feel like a nightmare to Galliano, given that his new collection launches in a few days and his employer, who he has served well for some time, seem to have thrown him to the wolves.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5167 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 12:12:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5167 In reply to Anonymous.

I think it is important to find out the facts before making harsh judgements. I have heard that the couple insulted him, which provoked retaliation. Galliano’s bodyguard was present , tried to calm the situation and reported the matter to police. Several witnesses have already said that he didn’t make anti-semitic racists (though he may have made a refernce to “Asians”which may have been racist). I think Dior jumped in without gaining the facts and if I was Galliano, I would be very unhappy with the way he has been treated by them. Dior’s statement seemed to prejudge Galliano as guilty.

]]>
By: Anonymous http://198.46.88.49/style/fashion/galliano-strikes-back-defamation-lawsuit-filed-against-couple-who-alleged-anti-semitism#comment-5166 Sun, 27 Feb 2011 11:24:00 +0000 http://198.46.88.49/?p=18719#comment-5166 Don’t see why he is ‘striking back’. His comments were completely offensive and inappropriate and as a result he is being held accountable for it. His suspension from Dior is completely expected and appropriate.

]]>